Selecting a criminal defense attorney or expungement lawyer who suits your needs is a daunting task. It is vital to pick a criminal attorney who fulfills your requirements for several compelling reasons. A suitable match ensures that your attorney grasps your apprehensions and you feel at ease communicating with them candidly. Open communication is indispensable for devising a formidable defense strategy.
You will be entrusting your attorney with significant confidence to handle a delicate and potentially life-changing situation. It is essential to have faith in their capabilities and trust that they prioritize your best interests. Different attorneys possess diverse areas of specialization and experience. Finding someone who concentrates on criminal law and has experience with cases similar to yours enhances your prospects of a favorable outcome.
Legal entanglements can be distressing and overwhelming. An attorney who is a suitable match will offer not only legal acumen but also emotional support, aiding you in navigating the process more seamlessly. Your attorney should be in sync with your preferred legal approach. Some clients may prefer a more assertive tactic, while others might opt for negotiation and settlement. A suitable match will ensure your attorney’s methods are in harmony with your objectives.
Finding the right criminal attorney can profoundly impact the outcome of your case and your overall experience throughout the legal process. It is also crucial to choose an attorney who fits within your budgetary constraints.
While I acknowledge my bias in recommendations (particularly towards myself and attorneys I collaborate closely with), I also recognize that I might not be an ideal match for every client. It is vital to establish a rapport with your attorney and select a lawyer who aligns with your objectives and budget. There are numerous qualified attorneys in Indianapolis, and I suggest considering a few below:

1. Josiah Swinney 

Josiah Swinney is a highly skilled trial lawyer with a proven track record in handling complex criminal cases. He has successfully represented high-profile clients in both trials and appeals, securing favorable outcomes and garnering public attention. Swinney’s exceptional work has earned him a spot in the Super Lawyers® Rising Stars list for three consecutive years, 2022, 2023, and 2024 ¹. This prestigious recognition is awarded to the top 2.5 percent of attorneys under 40, based on a rigorous selection process.
A distinguished alumnus of Indiana University’s Robert H. McKinney School of Law, Swinney graduated with honors. He began his illustrious career as a law clerk for Solicitor General Thomas M. Fisher, where he drafted multiple cases litigated in the US Supreme Court. Swinney’s expertise extended to advising the Indiana Attorney General on joining cases in other states and federal circuits. His outstanding performance led to his appointment as Deputy Attorney General, serving his community.
Currently, Swinney practices in trial courts across Indiana, the Court of Appeals, and the Indiana Supreme Court. His impressive wins are published on Casetext and Westlaw. To contact Indianapolis Criminal Attorney Josiah Swinney, you can visit his website by clicking here.

2. Jeff Cardella 

Jeff Cardella launched his legal career in Indianapolis as a criminal defense attorney, fiercely protecting his clients’ Constitutional rights against government overreach. With extensive experience in every facet of the criminal justice process, Cardella has successfully navigated jury trials, court trials, suppression hearings, post-conviction relief, forfeiture proceedings, 1983 civil rights actions, appeals, oral argument, probation revocation hearings, expungement, sealing of records, hardship license petitions, specialized driving privileges petitions, and plea negotiations.
Cardella’s office has earned recognition as one of Indiana’s top ten law firms by the American Institute of Criminal Law Attorneys. He has also been honored as one of the top ten criminal defense attorneys in Indiana under forty by the National Academy of Criminal Defense Attorneys. Cardella has taught criminal law at the Indiana University School of Law and served as a Judge pro tem in Indianapolis. His notable cases include representing a fellow criminal defense attorney, an Indianapolis Metro Police Officer, and two former Marion County Sheriff’s deputies.
Cardella filed the landmark Federal Class Action lawsuit Washington v. Marion County Prosecutor, which led to Indiana’s vehicle forfeiture statute being deemed unconstitutional under the Due Process clause of the US Constitution. He co-authored the amicus brief for the United States Supreme Court case Timbs v. State of Indiana, resulting in the Supreme Court ruling that Indiana’s forfeiture attempts were unconstitutional under the Excessive Fines clause. Cardella successfully handled over a dozen lawsuits against the Indiana Department of Corrections, challenging solitary confinement procedures under the Due Process Clause. He also filed several successful lawsuits against the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department for arrests violating the First Amendment.
Cardella’s mission is to provide exceptional legal representation at reasonable prices, recognizing that each client is an individual, not just a case file. He believes that everyone deserves a vigorous defense, regardless of the charges they face. If you have additional questions about Jeff Cardella’s services and practice areas, click here. If you have any questions about your case, and wish to speak with an Indianapolis Criminal Defense Attorney, Indiana Expungement Attorney, Indiana Forfeiture Lawyer, or Indiana Civil Rights Lawyer, and are looking at the higher end of the price spectrum, and wish to speak to Indianapolis Criminal Lawyer & Expungement Attorney Jeff Cardella, you can visit the website for the Law Office of Jeff Cardella Criminal Defense Attorney & Expungement Lawyer in Indianapolis Indiana by clicking here

3. Christina Gomez

Christina Gomez is a dedicated criminal defense litigation attorney and expungement lawyer serving Indiana, with a focus on Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Madison, Henry, and Monroe counties. Her practice centers on criminal law, encompassing defense, expungements, DUI/DWI, and other drug- or alcohol-related offenses, as well as sentence modifications. Gomez also litigates cases involving civil rights violations, due process infringements, and abuse of power by law enforcement and government entities.
As an affordable criminal lawyer, Gomez offers flexible payment plans for criminal cases. Her personal background, having grown up in the inner city of Los Angeles, California, has instilled in her a unique perspective and fervent advocacy for individuals facing crises, accusations, or governmental actions.
Gomez earned her undergraduate degree in History from California State University Dominguez Hills in Southern California. She later received her Juris Doctor (J.D.) from the Robert H. McKinney School of Law. Outside of her practice, Gomez values family time and often explores Indiana’s State Parks with her loved ones.
For inquiries about criminal matters in Indiana, you can contact Affordable Indianapolis Criminal Attorney Christina Gomez by clicking here.

4. Stephanie Renner

The law office of Stephanie Renner specializes in criminal defense, expungement, prenuptial agreements, and divorce cases. As an affordable criminal attorney, Renner offers flexible payment plans for numerous cases. Renner earned her law degree from Indiana University’s Robert H. McKinney School of Law. Following graduation, she gained extensive experience in criminal defense at both the state and federal levels as a law clerk for J. Edgar Law Offices.
Prior to attending law school, Renner attended Butler University, graduating with a Bachelor of Arts degree in 2016. Before pursuing her law career, she worked as a bailiff in the Marion Superior Court, Civil Division, under Judge Joven. Renner is known for bringing her canine companions to the office, affectionately referring to them as her “para-beagles.”
For individuals seeking an Indianapolis Criminal Lawyer and Expungement Attorney, Stephanie Renner’s office provides dedicated representation. To learn more about her services or schedule a consultation, please visit her website by clicking here. To contact low cost Indianapolis Criminal Lawyer and Expungement Attorney Stephanie Renner, you can visit her website by clicking here.

5. Bob Hill

Bob Hill is a seasoned attorney who currently helms the Marion County Public Defender Agency. Although he typically doesn’t take on cases personally, he oversees a team of skilled deputy criminal lawyers who adeptly handle criminal cases throughout Indianapolis. For numerous individuals unable to afford private legal counsel, public defenders offer an exceptional and viable alternative.